Costco has long been a go-to destination for bulk buys and delicious, affordable food court staples. But over the years, many beloved items have been quietly pulled from the shelves or taken off the menu, leaving loyal fans heartbroken. From decadent cakes to iconic food court classics, these 14 discontinued Costco favorites are ones we’ll never forget—and wish we could enjoy just one more time. Here’s a look at what we lost, why they disappeared, and what you can grab instead.
1. All-American Chocolate Cake
This towering, rich chocolate cake was a Costco bakery icon. Layer after layer of moist chocolate goodness, it was the perfect dessert for gatherings, birthdays, and anytime you needed to feed a crowd.
Why It Was Discontinued
The exact reason remains unclear, but rising production costs and a shift toward smaller, healthier desserts may have played a role in its departure.
Recommended Alternative Product
Costco’s Tuxedo Chocolate Mousse Cake is a delicious and fancy substitute, but nothing will truly replace the All-American Chocolate Cake in our hearts.
2. Churro
Costco’s legendary churro was a crunchy, cinnamon-sugar delight that was perfect for a sweet snack after a bulk-buy shopping spree.
Why It Was Discontinued
In 2020, the pandemic forced the removal of the beloved churro as Costco scaled down its food court menu.
Recommended Alternative Product
The new, larger churro that has since returned is tasty, but many claim it doesn’t quite live up to the original.
3. Combo Pizza
This pizza was piled high with pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions, olives, and mushrooms—everything you’d want in a hearty, satisfying slice.
Why It Was Discontinued
The combo pizza was removed during the pandemic to simplify operations, and sadly, it never returned.
Recommended Alternative Product
Costco’s pepperoni or cheese pizzas are still available, but they lack the variety of toppings that made the combo pizza so special.
4. BBQ Beef Brisket Sandwich
A BBQ lover’s dream, this sandwich featured tender beef brisket smothered in a sweet and tangy BBQ sauce, tucked inside a soft bun.
Why It Was Discontinued
Despite being popular among some, this item was discontinued due to its higher price point and niche appeal compared to other food court offerings.
Recommended Alternative Product
Try the Chicken Bake, a hearty and affordable alternative still on the food court menu.
5. Hand-Dipped Ice Cream Bars
Costco’s hand-dipped ice cream bars were a frozen masterpiece—vanilla ice cream dipped in rich chocolate and rolled in nuts.
Why It Was Discontinued
With growing emphasis on streamlining the menu and health-conscious options, this indulgent treat was sadly phased out.
Recommended Alternative Product
The Kirkland Signature Vanilla Almond Bars from the frozen section offer a similar flavor profile, but they’re just not the same as the fresh-dipped original.
6. Polish Dogs
The Polish dog was a fan-favorite, spiced and juicy, offering a different twist on the classic Costco hot dog.
Why It Was Discontinued
Costco removed the Polish dog from its menu in favor of adding healthier options, sparking disappointment among loyal fans.
Recommended Alternative Product
The classic Costco Hot Dog remains, and at $1.50 with a drink, it’s still one of the best deals in town.
7. Hot Turkey and Provolone Sandwich
This hot sandwich featured thick slices of turkey with melted provolone on a warm ciabatta roll. It was a comforting, satisfying lunch option.
Why It Was Discontinued
Costco has rotated food court items over the years, and this sandwich was eventually pulled to make room for new additions.
Recommended Alternative Product
Try the Chicken Caesar Salad or the Roast Beef Sandwich for a filling alternative.
8. Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels
Costco’s soft cinnamon sugar pretzels were a sweet, fluffy snack that paired perfectly with a mid-shopping coffee break.
Why It Was Discontinued
This item was removed as Costco revamped its food court menu to simplify operations.
Recommended Alternative Product
While pretzels have yet to make a return, the Churro is a comparable sweet treat.
9. Açai Bowl
A healthier food court option, the açai bowl was topped with granola, berries, and bananas, and became an instant hit for health-conscious shoppers.
Why It Was Discontinued
Costco’s food court saw significant menu changes during the pandemic, and the açai bowl was one of the casualties.
Recommended Alternative Product
The Smoothie is still available for those looking for a refreshing, fruity treat.
10. Kirkland Take-and-Bake Pizza
Costco’s take-and-bake pizza was a lifesaver for quick, convenient dinners. Whether it was pepperoni, cheese, or combo, you could bake up a pizza that tasted fresh out of a pizzeria.
Why It Was Discontinued
Costco eventually pulled the take-and-bake option in favor of selling frozen pizzas.
Recommended Alternative Product
The Kirkland Frozen Pizzas are still a great option, though they lack the fresh, made-to-order quality of the originals.
11. Kirkland Signature Turkey Burgers
These lean and tasty turkey burgers were a favorite for summer grilling, offering a healthy alternative to beef patties.
Why It Was Discontinued
They were removed from shelves, possibly due to lagging sales compared to traditional beef options.
Recommended Alternative Product
Try the Kirkland Signature Ground Turkey to make your own turkey burgers at home.
12. Kirkland Fruit & Nut Medley
This medley of dried fruits and nuts was a perfect healthy snack for on-the-go or a quick energy boost during a busy day.
Why It Was Discontinued
Costco is known for rotating its snacks, and this one didn’t make the cut.
Recommended Alternative Product
The Kirkland Signature Trail Mix offers a similar mix of flavors.
13. Kirkland Signature American Cheese
This creamy, melt-in-your-mouth American cheese was a must-have for grilled cheese sandwiches and burgers.
Why It Was Discontinued
The exact reasons for its disappearance are unclear, but changing consumer preferences likely played a part.
Recommended Alternative Product
Costco still sells Sliced Cheddar Cheese and Provolone, both excellent choices for your cheesy needs.
14. Kirkland Signature Light Beer
Costco’s own-brand light beer was a budget-friendly option for casual beer drinkers looking for a refreshing, no-frills beverage.
Why It Was Discontinued
Sales were reportedly low, leading to its quiet removal from shelves.
Recommended Alternative Product
Costco now offers a variety of craft beers and other affordable alcoholic beverages, like the Kirkland Signature Craft Brewed Ales.
Final Say
These 14 discontinued Costco products have left a lasting impression on members who crave their return. While Costco continues to introduce new and exciting offerings, these lost favorites remain in our hearts (and taste buds). Although we may never see these classics again, there are still plenty of Costco treasures to discover—both old and new. Which product do you miss the most? Let us know, and maybe, just maybe, it’ll make a comeback!
